Delhi chokes. Ministers talk. This is now an annual routine. When the air turns poisonous, those in power reach for two things — a microphone and an alibi.

The Delhi government recently apologised for the deteriorating air quality and, in the same breath, blamed the previous administration and neighbouring states.

The claim was that no elected government can fix the problem in “nine or ten months”. That is not an explanation. It is an admission of helplessness dressed up as honesty.

Arvind Kejriwal responded by pointing out that if Punjab’s air quality remains within acceptable limits while Delhi’s crosses into the “severe” zone, then the pollution is not being imported.

It is home-grown. He also mocked attempts to dilute the science behind air quality readings — a necessary response, because the science was being bent to suit politics.

At the national level, the government told Parliament there is no conclusive data linking higher AQI levels to long-term lung disease.

This line is technically safe and morally hollow. “Not conclusively proven” does not mean “safe”. It means convenient uncertainty. It means action can be postponed without saying so openly.

Then came the moment that summed up the state of public discourse: a senior minister compared AQI to temperature, as if air pollution were a neutral metric that rises and falls without consequence. The statement was widely ridiculed, but ridicule is not accountability. It was not a slip of the tongue. It was a reflection of how casually the crisis is treated.

The Political Playbook

The script is predictable.

First, blame farmers or a neighbouring state.
If that fails, blame weather patterns.
If that fails, blame previous governments.
If that fails, redefine the problem until it sounds abstract.

Stubble burning has been used as a political shield for years. It exists, and it contributes. But when Delhi suffocates while surrounding regions report cleaner air, the explanation collapses. Instead of revising the narrative, leaders repeat it louder, hoping volume will pass for logic.

The same strategy is applied to public health. By emphasising the absence of “conclusive” links, policymakers turn lived suffering into a footnote. Emergency room visits, breathlessness, and long-term exposure risks are reduced to statistical caveats. The effect is simple: urgency disappears.

Apologies Without Consequences

An apology that leads directly into blame is not accountability. It is time management. It buys a news cycle. It shifts responsibility to an invisible opponent.

Every winter brings the same announcements — construction bans, water sprinkling, odd-even proposals, school advisories. These measures are rolled out as reactions, not as policy. There are no clear deadlines, no enforcement data, no penalties that matter.

Landfills remain open. Dust control is sporadic. Vehicular emissions continue unchecked. Yet the messaging suggests the government is doing all it reasonably can. The implication is that the public must simply endure.

Why Language Matters

Political language shapes public response. When leaders downplay risk, people delay precautions. When harm is framed as uncertain, urgency fades. When responsibility is endlessly transferred, nothing moves.

This is not an abstract environmental debate. Flights are delayed. Schools install air purifiers. Children, the elderly, and those with respiratory conditions pay the price first. AQI figures are not theoretical. They correspond to coughing, wheezing, and reduced lung capacity.

And yet, every year, the crisis is treated as seasonal inconvenience rather than structural failure.

Performance Over Governance

Delhi does not lack reports, committees, or expert advice. It lacks execution. It lacks continuity. It lacks the political courage to say: this will be painful, this will cost money, and this will require enforcement that upsets powerful interests.

Instead, citizens get performance. Press conferences replace progress. Arguments replace action. Science is selectively cited, then selectively ignored.

The air clears eventually — not because of policy, but because the wind changes. And when it does, so does the political attention.

The Final Count

The public is not asking for miracles. It is asking for competence, honesty, and ownership.

Until those appear, the cycle will continue. Delhi will choke. Leaders will argue. Apologies will be issued without consequence. And the sky will turn grey again next winter — right on schedule.

ALSO READ | A Global Pact To Curb Plastic Pollution