The selection of Kiran Rao’s Laapataa Ladies as India’s official entry for the Oscars has stirred considerable debate within the film community. While the film has its merits, several factors suggest it might not be the optimal choice for representing India at the prestigious awards.

Here, we try to take an in-depth look as why the might not be the right choice!

Competition From Other Films

One of the primary reasons for the controversy is the competition Laapataa Ladies faced from other critically acclaimed films. Notably, Payal Kapadia’s All We Imagine As Light was a strong contender.

This film had already garnered significant international acclaim, including winning the Grand Jury Prize at Cannes.

Many critics and industry insiders believed that All We Imagine As Light had a stronger chance of resonating with the Academy voters due to its critical success and international recognition.

Genre And Appeal

Laapataa Ladies is a comedy of errors, a genre that historically struggles to gain traction with the Academy voters. The Best International Feature category often favors dramatic or socially impactful films that tackle serious themes.

Comedies, especially those rooted in specific cultural contexts, may not translate well to an international audience. This genre bias could hinder Laapataa Ladies from making a significant impact at the Oscars.

Industry Influence

The selection process for India’s Oscar entry has often been criticised for being influenced by industry clout rather than purely on artistic merit.

Laapataa Ladies is produced by Jio Studios and Aamir Khan, both of whom have substantial influence in the Indian film industry. This has led to speculation that the film’s selection might have been swayed by financial and industry power rather than its suitability for the Oscars.

Track Record Of Indian Entries

India’s track record at the Oscars has been less than stellar. Only three Indian films have ever been nominated for Best International Feature: Mother India (1957), Salaam Bombay! (1988), and Lagaan (2001).

The selection process has often faced criticism for not aligning with the tastes and preferences of the Academy voters.

Films that resonate well domestically do not always have the same impact on an international stage. This historical context raises questions about whether the Kiran Rao directorial can break this pattern.

Cultural Specificity

While Laapataa Ladies might be a delightful watch for Indian audiences, its cultural specificity could be a barrier to international appreciation.

The nuances of its humor and the context of its storyline might not be easily understood by a global audience.

This cultural gap can be a significant hurdle in the Oscars, where films need to appeal to a diverse group of voters from different backgrounds.

Conclusion

While Laapataa Ladies is undoubtedly a well-crafted film with its own charm, several factors suggest it might not be the best choice for India’s Oscar nomination.

The competition from more critically acclaimed films, the genre’s historical challenges, potential industry influence, India’s track record at the Oscars, and the film’s cultural specificity all contribute to the debate.

For a film to succeed at the Oscars, it needs to transcend cultural boundaries and resonate with a global audience, a feat that Laapataa Ladies might find challenging.

What are your thoughts on this selection? Do you think another film would have been a better choice?

ALSO READ | Wanting To Relax? Here Are Some Feel-Good Movies For You To Watch