Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Kottukkaali

Kottukkaali: A Missed Opportunity To Champion India's Global Narrative

October 7, 2024

PS Vinothraj's sophomore film, Kottukkaali (The Adamant Girl), after a world premiere in the Forum section at the 74th Berlin International Film Festival and a theatrical release in August, is now streaming on Prime Video.

The social drama, clocking in at just over 100 minutes, is rooted in rural Chennai.

It narrates the tale of a young girl, Meena (Anna Ben), who wants to marry her low-caste college mate but is refused by her family. She begins acting catatonically. The family of her maternal uncle, Paandi (Soori), whom she is to marry, takes her to a seer for exorcism.

The film's story is grounded in a portraiture of life in the countryside, involving dysfunctional human relationships, and resonating universally with themes of love, family, and patriarchy.

The camerawork and storytelling blend organically with the narrative, expressing so much with very few dialogues that even a viewer who doesn’t understand Tamil will have no trouble connecting with it.

The film primarily speaks the universal language of cinema. Scenes such as the tied rooster to the stone representing Meena's mental condition; a group of males holding on to the tempo and screaming as they spin it around with Meena in it; a charging bull stalling the road; or a tiny fly going into Paandi's eye are nuanced portrayals of a conflicting tale set in a non-urban setting.

It is the vision and creativity of the director, Vinothraj, that sets this film so dramatically apart, balancing cultural uniqueness with universal applicability.

Despite exhibiting a distinctive aesthetic approach, Kottukkaali went starkly unnoticed by the Indian masses upon its theatrical release because it was not mainstream enough. 

Hence, this goes on to make it another of the many glaring examples of how Indian cinema often splits into commercial superhits and more artistically inclined, indie productions.

The Indian audience is too inured to favour cinema that will run the box office, with formulaic and star-riven approaches.

Therefore, the value placed on critical appreciation operates on a different standard or scale than what appeals to the general public. Critical acclaim prioritizes artistic merit, innovation, and depth, while the masses usually favour entertainment value, accessibility, and familiarity. So, a film catering to the mass market dominates and tends to find box-office success easier than a low-budget film with artistic merits.

Kottukaali had the potential to be India's official entry for the Best International Feature category at the Academy Awards this year.

Its exploration of issues relevant to marginalized communities could have made a significant impact in addressing social concerns within Indian discourse.

ALSO READ | Bhoot Jolokia: A Treasure Hunt Film With A Promising Premise But A Disappointing Payoff

Share article on:


Developed By Lumenoid Studios
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram